In this story by Cin Forshay-Lunsford, a fifteen-year-old boy asks a classmate working in a magic shop if she can make a love potion. He is infatuated with a beautiful cheerleader who doesn’t know he exists, and has heard that the classmate has sorceress-like powers. After two clumsy attempts to gather materials needed for the potion from the cheerleader, she calls him a crazy “slug” and storms off. Fortunately the boy does find love, but it is unclear what role the potion played in it. Themes include magic, teenage crushes vs. genuine connection.