Saint Agnes Sends the Golden Boy
Cin Forshay-Lunsford

When Mrs. Stevens began her little speech on dream motifs in English literature, none of us was paying much attention. The majority of the class was staring out the second-story window watching the snow come down in thick waves and hoping school would let out early. Of course Marc Finkelstein was the exception. He was hanging on her every word as usual, and throwing out a lot of ass-kiss questions to prove he’d been paying attention. Chances are he’ll be named valedictorian when my class graduates. He’ll probably give some typical “God bless our parents, and our teachers, and America” speech, and I’ll be forced to throw up in one of those caps that looks like an album jacket that sprouted a tail.

Finkelstein was rattling away about nothing, so I absorbed myself in doodling on the cover of my spiral notebook. Just think, if school wasn’t so boring, I would never have become such a good artist. My specialties? Unicorns with wide eyes and tangled manes, roses, feathery-winged butterflies, pointed crosses, and daggers stuck through hearts.

Mrs. Stevens finished writing the assignment on the board. I took that as a cue to attempt to pay attention. It wasn’t easy. I’d just put the finishing touches on a heart that read, “Paul and Maddy,” and all I could think was how great it would be if Paul came crashing through the wall on the hood of a zebra-striped GTO. The rest of his band would be jamming out in the backseat. I could just picture Paul terrorizing Mrs. Stevens with nasty guitar riffs, sticking Marc Finkelstein’s head in the pencil sharpener, and cranking away till only his rubber duck-hunting boots would be left. Then he’d sweep me up in his arms and we’d take off amidst screaming guitars and applause. How come stuff like that only happens in music videos?

Mrs. Stevens adjusted her bra strap. “Today we will be reading a poem by John Keats entitled, “The Eve of Saint Agnes.” I’ve chosen this particular poem because tonight, January twentieth, is the actual Eve of Saint Agnes. Saint Agnes, in the Catholic religion, is the patron saint of young women, young virgins.”

The classroom erupted into laughter.

“Okay, that’s enough,” she said. “It’s nice to see I finally have your attention. As I was saying, according to legend, if a girl adheres to a specific ritual, Saint Agnes will reveal to her a vision of the man destined to be her true love while the girl sleeps.”

I quit drawing. This was getting interesting.

“The young girl in this poem is named Madeline.”

Everybody turned around to look at me, because that’s my name, too. What is this, kindergarten?

“Madeline abides by the ritual. She goes without eating, undresses in the dark, and stares straight ahead, praying to Saint Agnes. She dreams about her boyfriend. Of course, that is only the premise to this poem.” Mrs. Stevens smiled. “The actual story it tells is much more symbolic and complicated . . .”

I went back to drawing a Harley-Davidson insignia with bat wings coming out of it. Then I turned the notebook over because it was getting a bit cramped. On the back I began to write, over and over, “Maddy and Paul, tru luv 4 eva.”

I missed him so bad. I hadn’t seen Paul since Christmas. Almost a whole month. It wasn’t his fault really, considering he lives almost two hours away. Plus he has to practice his guitar, and rehearse with the band all the time. He wants to be something. That’s why I love him so much. Like the night I met him, he was doing a show at Paddywacks. Me and my girlfriends stood right in front of the stage. Paul had such grace, such charisma, it took my breath away. He played with his hips thrust forward and his back arched, whipping his head around like a gyroscope. You could tell he really loved his guitar, loved the things he could make it do. His facial expression changed from smiles to sneers, to grins, to lip biting with every chord change. Then he saw me looking at him and he strutted over and leaned down, playing just for me. He held me with his eyes, and I knew I’d always be his lady.

I traced a heart so deep in the cardboard that the penpoint went all the way through to the other side. I glanced up. Jack Mason was leaning over to see what I’d been drawing. I tried to hide all the tru luv’s and 4 eva’s with my elbow. Jack smiled at me. I felt incredibly stupid.

“Now,” Mrs. Stevens was saying, “let’s go around the room in order, and everyone read a stanza. Nancy, would you please start?”

“Saint Agnes’ Eve—Ah, bitter chill it was!”

Jack Mason looked around the room, counting heads, then made a mark next to the stanza he’d have to read. Then he went back to what he was doing. He’d been doodling too, but on the desk. He was a very good artist. I guess he thought school was even more boring than I did.

I’d watched him work since the first day of school. He’d started with the upper left-hand corner of the desk, working his way down. He sketched in pen, and sometimes in black marker. Three fourths of the desk was crawling with dragons, demons, wizards, skulls, and cobras. Once he’d come to class and the custodians had scrubbed the desk clean. For a split second this hurt look passed over his face. Then he’d wiped the powder grit off with the sleeve of his denim jacket and started all over again.

Our class didn’t finish reading the poem that period. Mostly because Marc Finkelstein had to comment on every other line. So, thanks to Ein(Finkel)stein, we had to finish it for homework.

“Don’t pack up your books yet,” Mrs. Stevens yelled over the conversations that burst out at exactly twelve twenty-six. “I want a short essay from you tomorrow also.”

There were immediate groans and protests. Suddenly the entire classroom was overwhelmed with a touching sense of school spirit. There was an urgent need to attend hockey practice, Spanish club meeting, drama production rehearsals—any semi-legitimate excuse to postpone an English paper.

Mrs. Stevens held her hands over her head like a referee.

“Okay, guys! That’s enough. I’m not asking you to read War and Peace. Just finish the poem. There’s only one page left. The assignment is on the sheet I’m passing out.”

The paper she gave us said, “In ‘The Eve of Saint Agnes,’ by John Keats, the heroine’s future is affected by her dream/fantasy. In a brief but well-constructed essay (three to five paragraphs should suffice), describe a dream or fantasy you have had. Would you want it to come true? Why or why not?”

I gathered up my books and glanced out the window. It had stopped snowing, my boyfriend was a hundred miles away, and I had another lousy homework assignment to do. There is no justice in the universe, on any level.

As soon as I got home from school, I called Paul’s house. His mother answered the phone. I put on my telephone voice.

“Hi. Can I speak to Paul, please?”

“Jeanie?” Paul’s mother asked brightly.

“No,” I said suspiciously. “It’s Maddy.”

“Oh. Maddy.” She hesitated. “Hold on a minute. I’ll see if Paul’s in.”

A few moments later she came back on the line.

“Honey, Paul’s in the shower. I’ll tell him to call you back later.”

“Thanks.” I hung up the phone.

I paced around the kitchen wondering who Jeanie was. I shrugged it off. Probably just a friend or a cousin or something. At five thirty, when my mother came home from work, I made a fire in the fireplace, and before dinner she whipped up two mugs of vin chaud—warmed wine spiced with cinnamon, cloves, and slices of orange and apple.

By six o’clock Paul still hadn’t called back, so I decided to phone his house again. This time he answered.

“Paul?”

“Yeah?”

God, did he sound sexy! Even just saying “yeah.”

“Hi, babe. I called you before. Didn’t your mother give you the message?”

“No,” he said. “I guess she forgot.”

I pencilled a heart on the kitchen wall by the phone.

“It’s so good to hear your voice,” I told him. “I miss you so much, you don’t know. Do you think you’ll be able to come down soon?”

“Oh, I don’t know. I doubt it. I’ve been really busy with the band and all . . . You know how it is.”

I tried not to sound disappointed.

“Yeah. Sure, it’s okay. I understand. Did you get the card I sent you? And the picture?”

“Yeah,” Paul said. “Thanks. I was going to write you back . . .”

A funny sort of tinge to his voice curdled the edges of his words. I cut him off.

“Listen—Paul? I was thinking. If you can’t make it down here, maybe I could come up there and visit you. I could take the bus. I bet my mom would say yes, if your mother says it’s all right.”

There was a long silence on the other end.

“Paul? Did you hear what I said?”

“I don’t think it’s such a good idea, Maddy.”

“Why not?” My voice came out too soft.

For the first time since I’d known him, Paul Matthews, budding rock musician and all-around champion talker, was actually having trouble with his public image. The monarch of social butterflies was at a loss for words.

“Uh . . . Maddy? Look, I’ve been meaning to talk to you,” he finally managed to say. “You’re a really nice girl. I know you deserve someone who’s going to pay more attention to you . . .”

I rubbed out the heart I’d drawn by the phone.

“Right now I just need a little time. I need to think, to get myself together. You understand, baby, don’t you?” He stumbled on. “I want to explore my feelings . . .” (Long, cowardly pause.) “Maybe see other people . . .”

I smashed the receiver down. My mother walked into the kitchen and put the glass mugs in the sink. She started babbling about nothing, then stopped when she saw my face.

“Maddy? What’s wrong? What happened?”

“Stupid, conceited idiot! I hate him! I do, Ma. I really can’t stand his guts.”

“Who? Paul? Wait . . . don’t tell me. He’s hocking your ankle bracelet to buy a new amplifier.”

“Ma!” I snapped. “It’s not funny. You think it’s a joke? Paul just broke up with me. I don’t find it amusing at all. I don’t . . .”

Her face went all soft, and she held her arms out to me. And suddenly I crumpled from the inside out.

She did what she could to make me feel better. My mom’s very patient. She nodded a lot and said, “Yes, yes, he is an idiot. I know.” She got upset when I told her I didn’t want dinner, but I had no appetite. Instead, I lay on my bed, listening to albums that reminded me of Paul.

I got sick of that after a while, and I tried to do my homework to get my mind off things. I read the rest of the poem for English, but I had a hard time concentrating, so the ending didn’t make much sense to me. When it came down to writing an essay, I was at a total loss. I had nothing to say. All my dreams and fantasies had been strangled with a phone wire. I hated everything.

Finally I couldn’t take it anymore. At nine-thirty I picked up the phone and dialled Paul’s number.

A girl’s voice answered this time.

“Who is this?” I demanded.

“Jeanie,” she snapped. “Who is this?”

I hung up.

I sank down on the floor of my bedroom, staring blankly in front of me. Twinkle, my Siamese cat, tiptoed over and gingerly tried to sharpen her claws on my lap.

“Get off!”

I pushed her away. Then I felt guilty, and I gathered her up in my arms. She flicked her ears at me, annoyed that I was crying. She doesn’t like for her fur to get wet.

Then I didn’t feel like crying. I felt like breaking things. My brain hurt. My English book was lying on the floor next to me, and that seemed as good an inanimate object as any to take out my aggressions on. I reached for it. Even through the blur of tears, the footnote stood out. I read it over and over.

“It was within Saint Agnes’s power to reveal a girl’s true love to her during a sleeping vision.”

True love. Was Paul my true love? Had he ever been? I’d written it enough times. I guessed wishing wasn’t enough to make it true. Saint Agnes! Ha! If Paul’s not my true love, who is? Yeah, who is? So the idea crept into my mind like mist taking shape. This is crazy, I thought to myself, as I pulled down the shades and turned out the bedroom light. There’s no such thing as saints. I kicked off my shoes and pulled off my socks by stepping on the toe of the sock with the heel of the opposite foot and then wriggling out of it.

“Saint Agnes’ Eve—Ah, bitter chill it was!”

I unzipped my jeans.

There is no Saint Agnes. Just like there’s no Santa Claus, or tooth fairy. My jeans were now lying in a crumbled heap on the floor. Maddy, you’re ridiculous. It’s not going to work. I pulled my sweater off over my head. Give it up, kid. Don’t forget not to look around the room. Just climb in bed. What does a saint look like, anyway? Probably like a kid. Like a young girl with pale skin and china-blue eyes. She’d have ripples of gold hair, like an angel, blush-pink cheeks, a sweet, timid smile.

Okay. No dinner, a dark room, no clothes, and no peeking around. That’s my end of the bargain, Saint Agnes, I thought to myself. Your turn now.

* * * * *

I woke from the dream with a start. When I turned on the light, strands of seaweed that had been wrapped around my bare legs turned out to be the damp, twisted sheet bunched at the foot of my bed. The great gray house was gone, and the lake had disappeared like vapor. I put my hand to my face and brushed back the tendrils of hair that stuck to my cheek. I looked down at my pillow, half expecting to see that a garland of purple sea lilies had fallen out of my hair onto the bed. But the sea lilies were only a dream like the rest of it, and my skin was damp with sweat, not sea brine. So Golden Boy, too, was only a figment of my imagination.

It was the weirdest dream I’d ever had, frightening, yet tempting and beautiful at the same time.

I’d dreamt I was with a group of friends. I don’t know who they were specifically, but we were visiting my uncle, who’d just bought a new house. It was more like a mansion, really—a great gray stone building with tiny windows and massive chimneys. The house was set back from a lake. Eerie, tangled trees overhung the water. Jagged black rocks jutted out of the green-gray surface at odd angles. One of them was shaped like the crown piece of a human skull.

On the left side of the lake a waterfall gushed and bubbled, but no mountain rose behind it. The water simply defied gravity, foaming up like a geyser on one side of the rock formation, and tumbling down the other in a silvery curtain.

Something glistened under the surface of the water. Goldfish, I thought to myself. But they were huge, more the size of small porpoises. They swam around the back of the rocks and came tumbling down the waterfalls. One of them was a muddy greenish brown, the other a shimmering gold.

I walked to the edge of the lake. My friends called me to come away. They begged me to go back to the house with them. All they kept saying was that it was dangerous, that something evil lurked beneath the calm water. I laughed, plunging into the lake to look for the strange creatures I’d seen sliding down the waterfall. I just had to get a better look at them.
I swam into a cave, a high tunnel of rock eight or nine feet long. Surfacing under the canopy of rock, I found that the water wasn’t all that deep. I could stand flatfoot and the water just covered my eyebrows, tiptoe and it only reached my chin. The cave was dank and cool, droplets of water dripping from the glistening ceiling two feet above my head, making ripples in the still water.

Suddenly, something brushed against my leg. I gasped and spun around in the water. It surfaced with a great splash. I was too shocked to move or scream. The waves his body had made calmed around him, and he stared at me with slanted green-blue eyes, the water dripping from his chin.

He was the most beautiful creature. His face was almost human. Almost. The bone structure was feline, with sculpted cheekbones and a solid jaw that looked like it could snap jugulars with a nip and a twitch. His eyes were like a cat’s too: huge, almond-shaped, with a slit of black pupil. He looked like a very attractive guy who was being mystically transformed into a lion and, as yet, had made it only halfway there. His mouth, nose, forehead were all normal. He even had a gold hoop earring in one ear. A mane of long gold hair floated in the water around his shoulders and hung in his eyes. His skin was golden, translucent almost. So much about him seemed touched by a pale light, the name immediately came to me: Golden Boy.

“Don’t be afraid,” he whispered.

He held out his hand to me. His fingers were long and bony, ending in pointed fingernails like claws. I took his hand and he dove under the water, dragging me down with him. That long under water, I should have been dead. But the water was like air in my lungs, and I moved freely and saw everything clearly.

Aside from the human face with feline characteristics, he had a man’s body, sleek and muscular. A spiky gold fin ran the length of the back of his neck to the small of his back. His human limbs ended at the knees, where his legs seemed to melt together, a huge fish tail waving underwater where his ankles should have been.

Something inside told me not to be afraid of him. He swam around me in graceful circles, brushing shyly against my legs. Then he swam away from me and I panicked, thinking he’d left me. Out of nowhere, he came up behind me and put his arms around my waist, curling his body into my back. I turned to him. He smiled, touched my face. Softly, he nuzzled into my neck, rubbing his face against my throat the way a kitten would.

I bent my head to his and showed him what a kiss was. He seemed to like it a lot. I laughed at his eagerness to try it again. Under water, laughter sounds like windchimes.

After we swam the length of the lake, we lay on a rock in the dying sunlight. Golden Boy had a friend, like him but a muddy brown color. He frightened me though. He wasn’t sleek and handsome like Golden Boy. He was emaciated. It looked like the skin was pulled so taut over his skeleton that the sinews and knobby bones would burst out like tree roots from the earth. Patches of scraggly black hair sprouted from the back of his skull, and his skin was mottled, diseased.

But he dove under the water, bringing up armfuls of sea lilies, which Golden Boy wove into a garland and set on my brow like a crown. From the shore my friends called to me to come back to them before it was too late. The muddy brown creature hissed at them, and they drew back.

“Just a few more hours,” I yelled to them.

Golden Boy took my hair in his hands.

“Don’t go back,” he said earnestly, “‘Don’t leave me.”

Beautiful, rare creature—how could I ever leave him?

It was then that I looked down at the murky water and the rotted skull bobbed to the surface. I drew back, terrified. Suddenly the muddy brown creature grabbed my leg and sunk his teeth deep into the flesh of my ankle.

I cried out.

“Swim! Swim away!” my friends screamed to me. “They’re evil, like ghouls or vampires. They devour people who come too close to the water’s edge.”

Horrified, I looked down at my ankle, expecting to see flesh torn away, exposed bone, flaps of bloody skin. But my ankle was fine. Not a scratch. The muddy brown creature shook his head and laughed, as if it had all been a joke. I looked over at my Golden Boy. He was laughing too. Relief passed over me like a wave. I smiled back at him. He was still graceful and handsome. He drew his lips back when he smiled, and for the first time I noticed the small, sharp fangs.

That’s when I woke up. I rehashed the dream in my head, trying to hold on to it. It seemed so real. I wanted desperately to fall back to sleep and finish it, find out what would have happened next. Would I have stayed? Was he beast or human or good or evil? I wasn’t ready to return to the dreamless world where mercreatures were an absurdity. I sat at my desk and headed the paper and began to write.

The next few days I didn’t think about Paul as much as I figured I would. Now and then I caught myself scheming up fiendish plots to torment Jeanie, but that was all harmless fun. Mostly I wondered about Golden Boy, and what the dream meant. I wondered about saints too. What kind of twisted sense of humor could this Saint Agnes have, to put terrifying, yearning visions in a young girl’s sleepy brain?

When Mrs. Stevens read my essay out loud to the class later that week, it sort of overwhelmed everyone. I guess because it was so weird. Even Marc Finkelstein was at a loss. She wouldn’t tell who wrote it, and I noticed several people looking casually around the room for telltale signs of the author. I kept my head down throughout the ordeal, diligently scribbling out the “Paul and Maddy” hearts.

The bell rang. Jack Mason grabbed my arm.

“This is for you,” he said, holding out a sheet of white sketch paper. “I drew your friend.”

Golden Boy was in the water, smiling enigmatically, holding a seashell. The waterfall was behind him, and the rocks, and the faint lines of a tree on the shore.

I sucked my breath in through my teeth.

“How did you know it was me?”

He shrugged. “I just did.”

Neither of us really knew what to say. He smiled awkwardly, “I liked your story a lot. Especially when you said how you’d have stayed with him anyway, even though you didn’t know if you could trust him. That part was cool. All of it was cool.”

“Thanks,” I said.

For the first time I took a good look at Jack Mason. His hair wasn’t as long and wild as Golden Boy’s, but it was a nice shade of blond. There was something else, but I couldn’t put my finger on it. Maybe the way his blue-green eyes lifted up at the corners.

“What did you write your paper on?” I asked him, because I didn’t know what else to talk about.

He fidgeted with his gold hoop earring. “You really want to know? I wrote about this fantasy I have, about this girl who sits next to me in English. Well, tell you what: take a walk with me to the coffee shop after school, and I’ll tell you all about it.”

I smiled at him, pulling on my fingers because my hands were shaking.
“You’ve got a deal.”

He smiled back at me, a wide reckless grin. It was then that I noticed the teeth . .

.